HRES-838-115
Motion to reconsider laid on the table Agreed to without objection.
Sponsored by Michael McCaul (R-TX)
What it does
This resolution would formally honor the life and contributions of First Lady Barbara Bush and extend the sympathies of the House of Representatives to her family. It is a simple resolution expressing the sense of the House and would have no binding legal effect, create no new law, and allocate no funds.
Who benefits
The Bush family receives a formal expression of condolence from the U.S. House of Representatives. Constituents who wish to see the House formally recognize Barbara Bush's public service and legacy would see that preference reflected in the congressional record.
Who is hurt
No individuals or groups would be materially or financially harmed by this resolution. There is no regulatory, fiscal, or legal mechanism that could negatively affect any party.
Supporters argue
Supporters argue that honoring former First Lady Barbara Bush is a fitting and appropriate use of the House's power to express its sense on matters of national significance. Barbara Bush was a prominent public figure who championed adult literacy and served the country for decades as the wife of a Vice President and President. Proponents contend that formal congressional recognition of her passing acknowledges her contributions to American civic life and reflects the House's longstanding tradition of memorializing distinguished public servants. They would say such resolutions cost nothing, harm no one, and provide meaningful recognition to a family that gave decades of service to the nation.
Opponents argue
Opponents argue that simple resolutions honoring private individuals or former officials, however distinguished, represent an inefficient use of limited congressional floor time that could be devoted to pressing legislative business. Critics contend that the House regularly passes dozens of such commemorative resolutions, and that the cumulative effect is to crowd out substantive debate on policy matters affecting millions of Americans. They would say that while Barbara Bush's contributions may be worthy of recognition, the appropriate venue is public statement or ceremony rather than a formal House resolution, and that Congress should reserve its formal proceedings for matters with direct legal or policy consequence.